The Overflowing Towel Bin and the “Broken Windows” Theory: Mastering the Critical Non-Essentials in Business

I noticed something fascinating at my local David Lloyd gym recently.

Dr. Harry Singh

Dr. Harry Singh Author - UK's No1 Aesthetic Mentor

As a Platinum member, we have the privilege of complimentary towels —a simple yet appreciated perk. After showering (and admittedly, I’m probably the slowest person in the showers, but that’s a story for another day), members are asked to place their used towels into a designated bin.

Here's the interesting part:

When the towel bin is neatly maintained, nearly everyone respects the rule, folding their towels tidily and dropping them in without fuss. However, the moment the bin becomes full or starts to overflow, standards drop dramatically.

Towels quickly pile up, often spilling over the sides, and members begin leaving them anywhere within arm’s reach. It’s remarkable how rapidly order can descend into chaos simply because of one minor oversight.

This phenomenon perfectly illustrates the principle behind the wellknown “Broken Windows” theory introduced by Wilson and Kelling.

They argued:

If a window in a building is broken and is left unrepaired, all the rest of the windows will soon be broken. One unrepaired broken window signals that no one cares, so breaking more windows costs nothing.

In business terms, author Paddi Lund calls these small yet impactful details “Critical Non-Essentials” (CNEs). These are the subtle details— like cleanliness, punctuality, courtesy, and consistency—that might not directly influence the main service or product you’re offering but dramatically affect the customer’s overall experience and perception of your brand.

Think about it:

When your waiting area is untidy, your appointments run late, or your team doesn’t communicate proactively, each of these small details signals to your customers that excellence and care aren’t indeed priorities. Just like the overflowing towel bin, these minor oversights become “broken windows” that encourage customers to lower their standards and expectations.

On the flip side, meticulously managing these seemingly small elements can dramatically elevate your business. Brands like Apple, Disney, and Ritz-Carlton invest extensively in their Critical Non-Essentials, setting consistently high standards for customer experience. This isn’t accidental—it’s strategic.

Today, I invite you to take a moment to reflect:

What minor detail in your business might be your “overflowing towel bin” right now?

Address it promptly, and you’ll not only avoid the “broken window” effect—you’ll build stronger customer loyalty, increase referrals, and reinforce your premium positioning.

Do you Want more Blogs?

Want to be No.1 in your Industry? Make it happen today

Get Free Updates

Subscribe for free updates on blog posts, success stories, and growth insights!

Where Medical Professionals Come For Best In Class